Davy Jones Consultancy

The world is spinning out of control....

The world is spinning out of control....

Thursday, 10 November, 2011

The world is spinning out of control.

A new report (http://bit.ly/tiXfGN) from the International Energy Authority (hardly a bunch of dangerous radicals) says we now have 5 years to significantly reverse the continuing growth in fossil-fuelled power stations. If we don’t, and there is lots of evidence suggesting we won’t, then by 2017 the planet will have reached the point at which we can no longer safely presume we can control climate change – “the door will be closed forever”.

Meanwhile, the Euro economic crisis deepens. Alasdair Darling chillingly argues the situation is “worse than 2008”. Governments topple as the markets dictate what must be done and by whom. Increasingly, the stark choice becomes clearer: democracy or markets.

Sleeping with the enemy
It’s long been a proud point of principle of mine never to agree with John Redwood MP. So imagine my angst when on Radio 4 yesterday he said there was a crisis of democracy in Europe, as governments fell only to be replaced by others (increasingly led by technocrats not politicians) seeking to implement the same austerity measures – “where is the role of citizens and democracy in all this?” Where indeed?

Whatever his cynical motivation for suggesting it, George Papandreou’s proposal of a referendum on the austerity programme in Greece at least raised the point about people having a say in this undemocratic rush to implement “the will of the markets”. Citizens in every country should have a right to vote on the draconian austerity programmes being foisted on them – virtually all the Governments lack a democratic mandate for them.

Who are “the markets”?
In the battle between democracy and the markets, we need to remind ourselves of something very important: there is no such thing as “the markets”. In reality, “the markets” is a term for the formal and informal mechanisms by which the super rich elite decides what is in its best interests. A brilliant recent article in New Scientist (http://bit.ly/nG1Tqw) recently showed that 147 big companies effectively control 40% of the global economy.

And remember these are the same people who brought about the financial collapse in the first place. And the same people who drive the inexorable consumption of the planet’s natural resources and resultant climate change. And I feel obliged to mention that these same people literally consume a vastly disproportionate amount of the world’s resources due to their grotesquely extravagant lifestyles. These people ARE “the markets” that we are told we must obey and which trample over our democracy.

Don’t want to say I told you so but…
In March, I posted a blog - Democracy and the Market – which concluded: “Greater citizen involvement will increasingly challenge the right of the markets to trample all over what people need and want. The dominant issue for the next year or two will be which of these trends wins out - democracy or marketisation.”
Democracy must win this battle – people should decide, not the unaccountable super-rich elite of “the markets”.

I think most people would agree that to let the markets determine how we organise our society is not a great idea and that we now have the tail wagging the dog. But as always, I find the left very unconvincing in its solutions. Planned economies have not proved successful either. If you could point to any useful alternative economic organisation that prioritises the health and wealth of people and planet I would be really interested in reading it.

We need another Marx right now - one proposing a viable alternative to the present lunacy that is practical and democratic rather than draconian and can deliver the goods and services we need to function.

Thanks.
Gina

Not sure I agree with Gina that we need another Marx at the moment. We clearly do not have that sort of time. Not sure of the way forward - clearly the level of consumption that most of us have come to expect is unsustainable. Somehow we have to get across to a wide cross section of people the importance of 'necessity' as a priority (a la William Godwin) and this does not mean the end of fun (does that make sense?)

Not sure I agree with Gina that we need another Marx at the moment. We clearly do not have that sort of time. Not sure of the way forward - clearly the level of consumption that most of us have come to expect is unsustainable. Somehow we have to get across to a wide cross section of people the importance of 'necessity' as a priority (a la William Godwin) and this does not mean the end of fun (does that make sense?)

Good blog, it ain’t easy to think of a way out... but is that the trap we have fallen for.....

I remember my six form economics lessons circa 1978 where we discussed the club of rome’s reports. Their macro-economic predictions then was that everything might start falling apart around 2020, and if nothing was done by around 1990 it was already probably just too late.

Of course I was at the City of London school (to my shame...but it offered a very good if private education... and it wasn’t my choice).

Maybe its all a conspiracy to blind everyone with fear so we just go along with some neo-liberal western agenda.

After all, are they so panicky in Iran, in Brazil, in Sweden or in Switzerland.

In fact are Swiss bankers maybe still rubbing their hands with glee?

Jez

Flat 4, 131 Ditchling Road, Brighton, Sussex, BN1 4SE
M 07932 616 843 T 01273 685 736 E davy@davyjonesconsultancy.co.uk